Online Marketplaces ...Back To The Future

InformationWeek has a very interesting article on Red Hat's move to having an online marketplace. This is consistent with the IQ strategy and certainly highlights that our approach and positioning are on the leading edge of the market. Other notable early movers include SugarCRM (SugarExchange), Joomla (Joomla Exchange) and Salesforce.com (AppExchange). Each of these companies have identified the value of leveraging their brands and user communities for growth - sort of like judo for nenw technology companies. I expect that we will see a lot more companies launching these types of initiatives. Having an Exchange is almost a requirement for Open Source companies but I also expect others such as Quickbase, Basecamp and even heavyweights like SAP to enter the fray.

Red Hat Talks Up Online Open Source Marketplace
Linux leader looks to certify the growing number of open source programs for its operating system and middleware platform. http://www.informationweek.com/story/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=198001606

Developing an Exchange / Marketplace strategy is one thing, being able to fund, execute and deliver on that strategy is quite another (sounds very late 90s .bomb) . So, what are the critical success factors? I believe that there are at least 5 :

1. Strategic Positioning - how does the marketplace contribute to making customer's existing investments even more valuable? how will the "owner" company benefit from the Exchange? Salesforce, SugarCRM and F5 have all done great jobs of launching Exchanges that are complementary to their core products. From what I have seen of the Red Hat Marketplace, they are missing the mark. Their marketplace is a venue to purchase a limited number of products that you can purchase directly or download for free with an extra click or two. Without value to the end customer, I don't forsee much traction.
2. User Base -the larger the user and partner base, the higher the probability of success. It stands to reason that the more consumers there are, the more developers are inclined to spend time building solutions that they can profit from.
3. Community - I draw a distinction between User Base and Community since one does not imply the other. To be successful there needs to be a vibrant Community which can add new applications (free and for a fee), post answers to user questions and most importantly refer others to the product / service / marketplace.
4. Ease of Engagement - ease of engagement is probably the most important aspect of building a dynamic community and network. If it is difficult to "engage" - customers and partners won't. In a world of distractions and countless alternatives, engaging and captivating customers and partners is critical. From sign-up through documentation to online chat and user forums, engaging customers and partners is the critical challenge.

Will there be a first mover advantage? Will established players such as Microsoft, SAP and Google enter the market and provide superior alternatives? We are in the early stages of an exciting time - traditional software, open source software and SaaS business models are colliding, business models are evolving and revolutionary new players are entering the marketplace (lousy pun...couldn't be avoided). I look forward to seeing how the first crop of Exchanges 2.0 take-off and evovle.